Sunday, January 17, 2010
Mountain Hardwear Monkey Man
I'm a fan of Mountain Hardwear's products, and have always had good experience with them. Given that, it comes as little surprise that, aesthetics be damned I've worn the MonkeyMan through thick and thin for almost two years now, and been extremely pleased with it.
Specs on the Monkey Man, per MH, are as follows:
Weight: 1 lbs, 2 oz / 514.00 g
Panel: Polartec® Power Stretch®
Body: Polartec® ThermalPro® Monkey Phur
[More After the Jump]
Be More Bad Ass Than Jack Bauer!
In the premiere we see Jack cut apart a dirty mattress in a NYC alleyway to make a pressure dressing for an injured informant. Shortly there-after, they are attacked by the bad-guys and after a brief shoot-out Jack declares that they need to run as he's run his HK USP dry. All the while, his charming (in a manly, rugged, way) leather musette bag is bouncing along on his hip empty as a politicians promise.
So, here's how you be more bad ass than Jack Bauer: Actually carry tools!
Once you have the skills, setting up a blow-out-kit for your daily carry bag is pretty easy!
Reloads should be carried on body for more reliable access, but if you've got the real estate having some in your bag probably hurts nothing.
Having a few tools in your pack can help you overcome difficult situations, and that too, isn't that difficult!
I'd bet that most of you readers, are bigger bad-asses than Jack Bauer. If you weren't before, you are now.
For those still struggling - BFE Labs is currently developing a 12-step program for recovering Bauerites who are having difficulty coming to grips with these issues. Additionally, a seven point book, “Seven Habits of Highly Effective Reluctant Anti-Hero's” is in the works.
Wednesday, October 21, 2009
CamelBak Delta-5 Hydration Vest Part Dos

At BFE Labs, we're doing things differently. We're taking some unconventional approaches in what we review, and how. By using different environments and uncommon purposes for some items, we can offer a greater contribution to the community knowledge pool than if we repeated the circumstances and settings of every other review written for any given product. Taking equipment, tools and techniques to the limit, across a range of circumstances, is the only way to truly prove them. This is one of the driving reasons why we've been evaluating load bearing equipment during extreme wilderness use, primarily during abandoned mine exploration.
These evaluations, beginning with the 5.11 Chest Rig, and continuing with James Mac's evaluation of the CamelBak Delta 5, are not the typical weekend on the gun-range evaluation that many readers are used to seeing in the popular tactical media. There is reason to this madness, and that reason is to provide a more complete picture of what these products can do, under a wider range of circumstance, than the typical evaluation.
We hope you find the same value in this approach that we do, and welcome your feedback!
Continuing this approach, we're pleased to bring you the second installment of James Mac's review of the CamelBak Delta-5 Tactical Hydration Vest.
James Mac is a technician at one of the premier weapons test facilities in the Western US, and brings a diversity of experience in engineering and the outdoors to the table.
CamelBak Delta-5 Hydration Vest Part 2:

After numerous trips into abandoned mines in the area, I remain pleased with how the CamelBak Delta 5 is holding up. I am impressed with this vest as a valuable option. It contains almost all of the bare-minimum gear that I want in just about any outdoors activity, be it hiking, camping, or subterranean exploration. What gear could not fit on the vest fits well in a thigh rig that I have setup as an addition to the vest. The Delta 5 holds enough water for a couple of hours of hiking or several hours of mine exploration. It also packs a blowout kit, a handgun, a pair of small binoculars, radio, compasses, MRE's, E-tool, boo-boo kit, and climbing hardware.

In the previous review “CamelBak Delta-5 Tactical Hydration Vest”, the layout and construction of the PALS webbing was praised. I would reiterate those praises. This quality of build allows the possibilities of gear attachment and placement to be just about endless. I continue to play with the layout of my vest, and plan to continue tweaking it until it is as good as it gets. This will probably mean having an adjustable layout for each activity, subterranean (with and without rope), hiking, camping, etc.

I've placed the items, (handgun, blow-out kit, binoculars, radio, compasses), that I might need at a moments notice up front where they are easily accessible. The items that would likely require removing the vest or having a buddy access were placed on the back of the vest (E-tool, boo-boo kit, MRE, climbing hardware).
The little touches that Camelbak included have proven themselves also. In particular the metal D-rings that are attached to the vest at the shoulders - I attached a carabiner to one of the D-rings to assist in cleaning rope, while going up a rickety ladder in a mine. It was nice to have my hands free while not worrying about the rope falling back down the hole. The belt attachment system is also nice, allowing the vest to stay firmly in place no matter what angle my torso is at, even when ending up crawling on hands and knees or sliding face first down inclines.
During rappelling the Delta 5 does not interfere with the rope or rappelling device. It provides ample room for use with a climbing harness (it gets a little crowded around the middle, but that seems unavoidable if rappelling with gear). I look forward to testing the vest further on rope, particularly during ascents.

The overall vest is holding up very well to all of my use/abuse. There are no busted stitches or threads, no rips in the material, and nothing has just fallen off [We've experienced all these issues with inferior gear in the mines. Ed.]. The construction of the vest is impressive. I have been very impressed with how the vest wears and handles the various situations I have thus far thrown at it. It has been hiking, scrambling/climbing, rappelling, down mines and caves, and it performs flawlessly.
I would recommend this piece of kit for anybody who needs their gear close by but doesn’t want/can’t have a pack. The possibilities and situations that this vest can be setup for and used in are literally infinite. I am going to use this vest for a long time to come, and I plan to get at least one more for more urban uses.
CamelBak Delta-5 Specs:
Hydration Capacity: 102 oz. [3.1L] (OMEGA™ Water Beast reservoir)
Cargo Capacity: 500 oz. [8.2L]
MOLLE compatible front and rear
Ambidextrous, no-slip butt stock seating
Ambidextrous metal sling/accessory attachment points
Velcro for ID and patches
Adjustible to fit most sizes, with or without body armor.
Heavy-duty, low profile drag handle
Wednesday, October 14, 2009
Beyond Has a Cool Catalog... and More!


I'm not really big on traditional “press blogging”. You'll never see many press releases (other than from BFE Labs) or similar updates here. There are some truly excellent blogs tracking product and systems developments in the tactical fields, such as SoldierSystems. I have no desire to compete with them.
But occasionally, I can't help but be impressed enough by a press effort or something other than the actual product in my hands, to want to share it.
Beyond Clothing managed to impress me today: I got one of their catalogs in the mail.
It's simple, one sheet of heavy glossy paper, folded. What makes it cool is that isn't not a read me, look at the pictures, type catalog. It's a touch, feel, see type catalog. On the interior are several 1.25”-ish swatches of various fabrics used by Beyond.
I'm a combined learner – My thinking and learning styles combine visual, tactile, textual and audiological. However, I'm also a builder, and having things in my hands is important to me. A lot of people are fairly similar, and actually having a thing in their hands makes a world of difference.
Beyond has grasped this concept with their catalog. It's pretty cool.
Cooler yet, their product offerings. I'm really impressed with the look of much of Beyond's clothing, particularly their Tactical offerings. I also find their ethos and methods notable. They seem to be an innovative business, dedicated to their end users. Several of their products are on my short list to purchase eventually, and I particularly want to try their BDU's out in some difficult places like the mines. When I do, expect to hear all about it!
Check them out, and get a catalog if nothing else!
(Yeah, I'm easily impressed by brightly colored small objects I can fiddle with... so what?)
Saturday, September 19, 2009
A Word on Reviews and Procedures
Primarily, it gives us a venue in which to elaborate on certain products without detracting from articles and tutorials. There are products and tools which merit significant attention, that cannot (and should not) be given in more general articles where it would distract from the main thesis. Many of these products, by themselves, have such a significant impact on the field that not making the effort to fully evaluate and report on them would put BFE Labs behind the power-curve – If knowledge is our product, we do a disservice to our readers and clients if we lack knowledge of a potentially life saving, or potentially dangerous, product.
Another advantage to evaluations and reviews is that they sometimes allow us access to tools we might not otherwise be able to field. When purchasing equipment for our own work, expeditions and training, we prioritize what we need the most urgently and consequently a large part of the evaluations done, and gear discussed, is our personal equipment. But, we are open to manufacturers supplying testing and evaluation samples, and in many cases will seek out those opportunities for special items. These evaluation opportunities allow us to access a range of products than may not be practical for us to purchase in the near-term. Manufacturer cooperation gives us the ability to provide more in-depth and relevant coverage of our chosen fields, more rapidly, than we might otherwise be able to. It also presents the manufacturer with opportunities for new, and sometimes different, feedback from our unique environments and experience, and the chance to reach our readers with their product.
We seek to provide both the end user, and the manufacturer, with evaluations that will contribute positively to what they know, what they do and how they do it. We greatly appreciate the manufacturers who've supplied us items for evaluation, and the relationships of cooperation and mutual respect that've been built from those experiences.
However – Reviews are not advertisements. We evaluate everything impartially, and without favor or dis-favor save what is incurred due to performance of the product being evaluated. We do not play favorites or give preference to those who give us products. Manufacturer submitted equipment and gear gets no easier a ride for being submitted, than it would if we purchased it.
If something sucks, we're going to say that it sucks, why it sucks and (generally) what we feel could be done to make it not suck. Our goal is to improve the field – Making end users aware of good products, warning them of bad, and contributing to the knowledge of manufacturers and suppliers.
Vice that, we are also not going to say something sucks if it does not. Whatever personal feelings we, or friends/associates of ours, may have about individuals or companies they have no bearing either way on our evaluations or reviews. Our goal is not to take-down manufacturers, or imply any qualities (positive or negative) about anything other than the product in question. We're not in the business of manufacturer or character assassination and pursue no agenda in our evaluations or reviews other than to provide bias-free testing and reporting on a given product while in actual use.
Similarly, we're not Twitter – There is, and will remain to be, a dearth of news releases and un-evaluated product announcements on the BFE Labs pages. There are already several excellent blogs in the field which specialize in that type of publication, and they are an excellent resource. BFE Labs is about proven solutions, not attractive ideas – If the attractive idea proves out in our use, then we'll report on it. We seek to be an experienced voice, that can be trusted to provide information grounded in actual use – End users, who can be trusted by end users.
In conducting evaluations and publishing reviews, we make our experience and knowledge freely available in the hope of bringing good things to life in these fields – Awareness of good products, greater knowledge of use of equipment and gear, and improved performance among end users, innovators and manufacturers.
Tuesday, September 8, 2009
A Link for the Fire Brothers & Sisters
VentEnterSearch: The Lost Art of the Fire Service
I'm not a structure fire guy, and my real-world experience with fire at all remains limited, but I've found valuable stuff for my own purposes on VentEnterSearch.
The content in particular that was linked on TPI, reminding me of the site, was their "Whats in your pockets?" page. Some really cool ideas, and for those not in the fire service, a good look at tools valuable in the urban environment when things go wrong. For those without the luxury of a shop full of tools, and looking for ideas for their disaster survival or urban escape & evasion/bug-out bags, this is a valuable bit of info.
Be safe out there!
Sunday, August 23, 2009
NuMask IntraOral Mask and Oropharyngeal Airway

I picked up a couple samples of the NuMask Inc., IntraOral Mask (IOM) and Oral Airway (OPA). While I've not had the opportunity to actually use the IOM, it seems to be a pretty neat idea.
Whereas a conventional ventilation mask fits over the mouth and nose, the NuMask IOM goes inside the front of the mouth, between the lips/cheeks and the teeth/gums. The IOM is enhanced by an oral airway which fits against it, in a fitted recess, providing positive engagement between the devices.
During mask ventilation with a conventional mask, ala the Bag-Valve-Mask, pressure against the face is required to keep it in place and ensure positive ventilation. This can be problematic (to say the least) in cases of facial injury where putting pressure against the face can make things worse.
While the trained provider is likely to counter the situation by intubating, that may be outside the skill level of initial responders. As the NuMask IOM removes the need to exert pressure against the face, it may be a viable option for First Responders, and Basic level providers (who in some area's still cannot intubate), for providing positive air pressure ventilation for maxillofacial trauma patients prior to intubation/arrival of a provider capable.
The NuMask may also have additional benefits, making the provider's life easier at least: Bagging, while regularly taught as a two person skill, is a single-provider task in the real world, and the ease and security of the IOM's placement may make that task somewhat less awkward. NuMask also produces a soft head-wrap type device to hold the IOM in place properly, without requiring hands on.
Traditional masks also have some difficulties in getting a proper fit over facial hair and other facial irregularities, which wouldn't be a problem for the IOM.
NuMask also advertises, and I would suspect rightly so, that the IOM is much easier to use in a variety of positions than a traditional mask, which can be difficult to properly hold in cramped or awkward quarters. For the extreme environment, the IOM may offer a lot over more conventional set-ups.
NuMask is currently giving out samples of the IOM and OPA set at www.numask.com – Stop by and grab one, and take a look at their other offerings.
I'm thinking their Intra-Oral Mask Bag Valve resucitator kit would make a nice, lightweight and compact, option for mine exploration/caving medicine.
Tuesday, August 18, 2009
Ultimate Survival Technologies Sparkie
Ultimate Survival Technologies has long been recognized as a producer of high quality and innovative survival solutions. One of their more noted innovations has been the BlastMatch one-handed fire starter. Successfully combining a large ferrocerium “steel” with a unique design, allowing for use when injured or disabled, the BlastMatch has been a hit for several years now. About the only complaint that anyone could come up with was that it wasn't exactly small. Late last year, Ultimate Survival Technologies introduced a smaller sparking unit, based on the BlastMatch concept, that deals with this “issue”.
Called the Sparkie, this tool features a similar one-handed operating concept, but using a smaller ferro rod, supported on an ABS carriage, and an overall smaller housing. The body of the Sparkie is ABS plastic, with a rubber sleeve for grip. The sleeve is either orange or a tan/cream color. The unit weighs 24-grams (.85 oz), and measures (closed) 2.3 x 1.2 x 0.7 inches (5.8 x 3.0 x 1.7 cm). The Sparkie comes packaged either in a plain cardboard box, or in a blister-pack for retail display, and comes with a cube of UST's excellent WetFire tinder.
To operate the Sparkie, the user has a couple of available options. The first is to place the end of the extended rod carriage against a surface, at a 75 – 90 degree angle, and with the thumb depressing the striker against the rod press down sharply. This pushes the ferro rod/carriage into the housing, against the pressure of the striker blade, which shaves the ferro rod to create sparks. The second option is to use the thumb, or extended forefinger, to operate the carriage while applying force with the closed hand or thumb to compress the thumb tab above the striker.
CamelBak Delta-5 Tactical Hydration Vest


(James Mac, of BFE Labs, has been working on refining his personal set-up for first and second line gear, and has picked up a CamelBak Delta-5 Tactical Vest in the process. He's taken it on various excursions and put it to repeated use as a load-bearing system for abandoned mine exploration. His professional responsibilities to the weapons lab where he works have kept him from penning a full review, but he prepared the following initial impressions awhile ago and wanted to go ahead and run them until he could finish a complete review.)

First impressions: Straight out of the “box” the Delta 5 looks like a simple LBE vest that is covered in MOLLE compatible webbing. It has an insulated pocket for the included 102 oz. bladder. It also has an attachment system for a belt, it seems that donning and doffing multiple times will be inconvenient. I have estimated about 15 minutes to doff and don. The vest is fully adjustable, including shoulder adjustments. Once adjusted it felt really comfortable. I ended up wearing Under Armour heat gear under the vest because of the form fitting nature of the rig. I have it setup up with numerous 5.11 VTAC pouches. I have it loaded with my essential must-haves, including: Blow-out and boo-boo kits, my XD-45, E-tool, MRE's, binoculars. All this gear weighs in between 40 and 50 pounds. The weight was well balanced enough to feel like 20 pounds. It worked well while scrambling up and down rocks. Feels good for hiking, looking forward to taking it in a cave or a mine. [Editors note: James has had this rig down hole since he wrote this, and came away pleased with its performance]
I have done some experimenting with carrying a pack on top of the Delta 5. With the pouches removed from the back of the vest it is very easy to adjust a pack to fit well. It is helpful that my normal pack has the ability to carry MOLLE pouches. I have timed myself in taking the pouches off my pack and putting them on the vest (already doffed), it takes about 6-7 minutes; even in the dark. [Ed.: CamelBak's PALS webbing is well sewn, with even spacing, making attaching and detaching pouches far less of a hassle than some systems with inconsistent spacing].

[Editor adds:]
Specs on the CamelBak Delta-5 are as follows:
Hydration Capacity: 102 oz. [3.1L] (OMEGA™ Water Beast reservoir)
Cargo Capacity: 500 oz. [8.2L]
MOLLE compatible front and rear
Ambidextrous, no-slip butt stock seating
Ambidextrous metal sling/accessory attachment points
Velcro for ID and patches
Adjustible to fit most sizes, with or without body armor.
Heavy-duty, low profile drag handle
We'll be posting a finished review of the Delta-5 in the future, and hopefully at some point James will further elaborate on his overall kit, and the evolutionary process behind it.
Tuesday, June 16, 2009
5.11 Chest Rig - Initial Impressions
For awhile now I’ve had interest in playing with some simple chest-rig configurations for somewhat unconventional purposes. Namely, supporting firearms not commonly supported by modern tactical gear, and load-bearing for non-tactical purposes. The easiest solution for adapting to something unconventional is to start with a highly modular platform. The obvious conclusion is a strictly MOLLE chest rig. Also as noted in some previous writing, this type of load bearing equipment arose as a possible solution for mine exploration work as well.
There are a bevy of options for this type of rig out there, almost everyone makes some variant of a plain-MOLLE chest rig. One of the more recent entrants into that field is 5.11
Known for their clothing, 5.11 Tactical has only more recently begun to expand their line into tactical gear proper. Among other things, they offer a small handful of packs and bags, and a growing range of MOLLE compatible pouches and rigs.
These offerings seem to be aimed at providing a low cost alternative, that delivers higher quality than airsoft grade drek without the price of higher end gear. I don’t think anyone is expecting Eagle, Tactical Tailor, Emdom or Paraclete for the prices 5.11 is asking, including 5.11 themselves.
The chest rig from 5.11 is a simple design, using basic features to create a robust platform rather than going for anything too “whiz-bang”. The rig is a simple mesh panel, with PALs webbing across the front, and a mesh pocket its width across the rear. The X-harness attaches to the chest rig via four UTX Flex side-release buckles, two at the top and one on each side. The construction of the rig seems solid enough. I’ve seen more bombproof stitching methods than are used here, but I see no obvious problems with those used. Again, for a $29.99 product, this is a step above what is commonly available for those prices (i.e. airsoft crap). It has certainly, in my initial outings with it, held up better than airsoft-grade crap.
(More after the Jump)
Thursday, June 4, 2009
The SWAT Tourniquet
The essential element of bleed management in the tactical setting is the tourniquet. It is not ideally a stand alone tool, but in many ways it remains the tool. If no other tool is available, a tourniquet can be placed with life saving effect. Even when other tools are available, tourniquet placement on active extremity hemorrhage can mean the difference between a patient surviving to the point of further management and not. Tourniquets are the tool a fighter can apply rapidly and quickly, with a high level of certainty that blood loss will at least be reduced, and return to the fight after doing so.
What It Is:
There are a bevy of “tactical” tourniquets on the modern market. Primarily one hand designs, as necessitated by the realities of self care and the tactical environment, but of all shapes, materials and sizes. Many of them are overly complex, and yet others are absolutely simple.
Of the available options, it probably doesn’t get simpler than the Stretch, Wrap And Tuck Tourniquet (SWAT-T) from TEMS Solutions. The SWAT-T is absolutely minimalist design at its finest and most functional, being a simple band of latex-free rubber approximately 4-feet long, and 4 inches wide. Simple as it is, when properly applied the SWAT-T can deliver complete tourniquation of even larger limbs (muscular legs at the thigh).
To use the SWAT-T as a tourniquet, it must be wrapped around the limb (proximal placement, standard application for any tourniquet) under tension. Pulling the SWAT-T, stretching the material constantly as it is wrapped, allows it to be wrapped extremely tightly. Once wrapped, to secure it, you simply lift an edge of the material and tuck the running end firmly under. The material, being somewhat self adhering, pulls down against itself as it tries to relax into its unstretched state. This both locks the running end firmly in place, and pulls the tourniquet even tighter on the limb. Application is fast, secure, and effective.
On the SWAT Tourniquet website, www.SwatTourniquet.com, several videos of it being applied are posted. In each video, vascular Doppler is used to measure flow (or, lack of flow as the case is) after application. The flow in both leg and arm applications is completely occluded. This has been duplicated in independent review posted by a moderator on the Professional Soldiers board, and quoted in a Powerpoint issued by SWAT Tourniquet.
In addition to functioning as a tourniquet, the SWAT-T can function as pressure dressing, elastic wrap or in an emergency splinting role. The tourniquet is printed with a series of directions and simple symbols, indicating when it is stretched enough to provide the proper amount of pressure for effective tourniquation. When applying it for other purposes, you simply don’t stretch it as much. The visual indicators on the tourniquet are a very effective guide for applying it correctly.
The developer has reported that those unfamiliar with the SWAT-T, upon being handed it and looking at the instructions, take an average of around twenty seconds to successfully apply it. Given its intuitive simplicity, clear packaging instructions and on-board visual feedback, this should be no surprise.
Sunday, May 31, 2009
Chest Rigs in Abandoned Mines and Other Ideas Explored

This past Saturday, I, along with Ian Wendt of Special Circumstances and two of our friends, went for an extended wander. It was a great single day of hiking and exploring. Eight hours of near-non-stop movement through pretty rough country (7000 - 8000+ feet elevation, with rapid drops and rises between that range), plus some forays into abandoned mines.
We had struck out with the hope of entering a specific mine, but found our way blocked, and rather than give up we went for a wander. Looking, of course, for other dark holes to poke around in. We found a few, mostly short and un-interesting. The last one however provided a few hours of good exploration and some opportunity to test some things out.
The folks from 5.11 were kind enough to send me one of their MOLLE compatible chest rigs to T&E. I don’t think they had abandoned mine exploration in mind when they provided the sample, but this was my first opportunity to seriously use the rig after receiving it. }
Our little crew of intrepid idiots… erhm, adventurers, has been talking about changing up our load-bearing methods for working in the mines and using chest-rigs or load-bearing vests has come up as a very workable idea. This was the first time any of us has tested it however.
Wednesday, May 13, 2009
Carrying the Blow Out Kit
There will always be the willfully ignorant, who want to deny the need for medical skills in the arena of violence, but worse yet are those who are aware and yet carry nothing. Particularly they who have at least a modicum of skill for managing life threatening penetrating injury, and yet still do not carry a blow-out-kit. Their reasoning often involves a certain degree of the aforementioned willful stupidity, but it is mostly complacency. They didn’t need a blow-out kit yesterday, the gear takes up a lot of space, and they’re only going out for a little bit, and so on and so on.
In my experience personally, and with students and friends, this type of “reasoning” is pervasive, and it almost always revolves around a single point: The gear is bulky, and takes up a lot of real estate.
While true, realistically, this is a cop out. A handgun and two reloads are bulky and take up a lot of space to carry too. I think if medical gear had as ego boosting an image as a handgun, perhaps more people would carry it – A bad guy full of smoking holes will however always be a more appealing mental image than you full of smoking holes.
That said, yes, a blow-out kit can be a hassle to carry, but it can be done.
Notes on Mine Exploration Gear
The wrecking crew and I are talking about going back into the mines (a mine, some mine, any mine) sometime soon. It is one of those things that, once you’ve started, get’s harder and harder to resist. The need to go back in starts building, a curiosity at first and then a driving, desperate, need. It’s a great feeling.
With this coming up, and the recent overview of abandoned mine exploration, I’ve been thinking over some gear selection, and wanted to make a few notes.
Thursday, March 30, 2006
Is Stainless Steel Good Enough for a Knife Blade?
As a knife-maker, and the moderator of knife (or knife related) forums for a few different internet bulletin boards over recent years, I very often hear people talking about high carbon steel being the only choice for a good knife. If they don’t say it directly, it is often something they have heard from someone else, saying something like “I was told if a steel doesn’t rust it wont make a good knife.”
Of course the up-shot of this is very often that stainless steel gets pandered, even unintentionally, and very good knives made of stainless are ignored or over looked. This is quite unfortunate, because the right stainless steel works extremely well.
I have a theory about this little phenomenon though - It is an issue of Carbon content.
Before we continue, let me establish a few “definitions”. Steel, in general, is divided up into two categories, and five subcategories that apply to the two main ones:
- Simple Carbon Steel – Steel of all types with less than 13% Chromium content.
- Stainless Steel – Steel of all types with more than 13% Chromium content.
Ø Very Low Carbon – Steel with up to 0.05% carbon content.
Ø Low Carbon – Containing 0.05 – 0.2%
Ø Medium Carbon – Containing 0.2 – 0.5%
Ø Medium-High Carbon – Containing 0.5 – 0.8%
Ø High Carbon – Containing 0.8% and higher
The higher the carbon content the better, but we’ll get to that momentarily.
Now, in the knife world the term “High Carbon” alone takes on its own meaning – it is used to indicate a high carbon, Non-Stainless, blade steel. Stainless, or high carbon stainless, is the commonly used term for stainless steel blades.
The old-school wisdom about blade-steels having to be High Carbon steel probably comes from a combination of two things - early stainless steels having low carbon content (a hypothesis on my part, I am not a historical metallurgist), and cheap knives being made from poor (low carbon content) stainless steels.
You have a historical precedent of old-school bladesmiths and knife-makers saying "That new fangled stainless doesn’t make a good knife", combined with a current perception of stainless as a poor steel thanks to low quality knives. Although the latter is primarily supported by el cheapo Pakistani and Chinese imports, major companies such as Buck, Case, the now defunct Schrade, and Gerber, who are to a large extent makers of the knives carried by "the common man", use low grade stainless steels, that give poorer performance compared to the carbon steel of the knife the user may have carried before, or of a similar high carbon steel bladed offering.
Here's the difference between stainless and non-stainless (high carbon) steels, chromium. Anything less than 14% chromium, and its a carbon steel - over 14%, its not. That’s it. The chromium content has some impact on the quality of the steel as a knife blade, but comparatively little next to carbon content. Carbon content makes all the difference in the world. A good quality stainless steel, in addition to having the stain resistant (no steel is truly rust or stain "less") qualities provided by the Chromium content of the alloy, must also have a high carbon content.
Now, I am not a metallurgist, I’m just a knife-maker, but my understanding of this is as follows: Carbon is the essential element in hardening steel. When steel is heated to a certain temperature (this temp. will vary depending on carbon levels) the ferrite (pure iron) reacts with the carbides causing a transformation from the cold structure of the steel into a metastable state called austenite (a face centered cubic crystal with ample space for carbon atoms). As this critical temperature at which the change begins is passed more austenite pools and consumes the ferrite. When all the ferrite is consumed the steel consists of austenite and undissolved carbides. Without getting too involved here the transformation to austenite results in a new grain-structure, held by the undissolved carbides. As the heat is maintained at the critical temp (or increased for some alloys) the remaining carbide is dissolved, allowing the grain structure of the austenite to develop fully. Remember, this is a state of hot steel.
To harden, the steel in its austenite state is rapidly cooled (rapidly varies from steel to steel, and depending on the desired hardness, cooling is a controlled process, but to harden the cooling must be faster than natural heat dissipation by a considerable amount) – this cooling traps carbon atoms inside the face centered cubic structure which distorts them into a tetragonal shape that is under immense stress. This stress equals hardness. The end result of rapidly cooled austenite is called “martensite”. Without carbon, this entire process is impossible. Without the right amount of carbon, the process is possible but will never bring the steel to a hardness suitable for a knife.
(After all of the above, the hardening process, the steel is “tempered”, reheated slightly to relieve a little of the stress on the carbon atoms, and achieve a balance between necessary hardness, and toughness: the shock resistance of the steel. Too hard is also too brittle, not good for blades).
Other elements in the alloy, such as Chromium, Tungsten, Molybdenum, etc. can have their own little impacts on the hardening process, but without carbon its moot.
So how much carbon content is enough in Stainless Steel? Well, the lowest acceptable grade of stainless is generally considered 440A stainless, which has 0.60 carbon content, 440B has 0.70 and good old 440C has 0.95 – 1.20. Comparatively, 420J2 (which is the industry standard for Chinese junk knives) has only 0.15 – lending to the perception of stainless as a low carbon poor quality steel.
Industry standards for stainless tactical knives (especially at the custom level) are ATS-34, 154-CM and S30V.
ATS-34 and 154CM are pretty much the same steel although they differ in manganese content, one is simply a Hitachi product and the other from an American mill (Crucible, maybe, but I do not remember), their carbon content is the same 1.05
S30V has a carbon content of 1.45 (which is similar to the carbon content of top-end High Carbon tool steels, such as D2 [which is near a stainless, but just not quite enough Cr.]).
The best stainless blade steels are ones with a carbon content of 0.90 or greater. These steels are capable of achieving good hardness, for long term edge holding and performance, and if properly handled during hardening and tempering are also tough in addition to their wear resistance.
That’s a pretty quick (yeah right!) and dirty summation of how it works, so if there are any metallurgists here forgive me for any errors.








