
Growing up in the hinterlands of New Mexico, and continuing to live, work and play in suburban, rural or plumb bum-fuck-Egypt areas, I’ve had my share of run ins with snakes. There have been, of course, the harmless run ins, which I usually encouraged. Namely, the bullsnakes and racers I’d catch as a kid, shutting them up in a terrarium for a week or two before depositing them back where I nabbed them. Then there were the run ins with the less desirable element of the serpent world – Venomous snakes, particularly rattlesnakes.
I have stepped on, kicked, almost sat on, put my hand down on, been crawled over and been struck by both Western Diamondback and Prairie Rattlers. I’ve had close calls of less dramatic nature with most other species of rattler in the southwest, to include Mojave and most recently Timber rattlers.
After this most recent encounter, while hiking to a mountainous mine adit, I was musing on my personal history with rattlers. I mentioned to my companions that eventually my snake luck is going to run plumb out, though I honestly hope not. Having my boots struck but not penetrated is more than close enough for me.
But this encounter and my experiences in the past, led me to doing a mental review of what I know about snake bite medicine. What I came up with was both woefully short, in my estimation, and far better than what I hear being repeated around various communities I’m part of.
Given that, I thought it might be beneficial to put together a little something on venomous snake-bite, and good practices related there-to. Something between an actual article, and a literature review. Both for my own benefit, as I expand what I know, and to build on the obvious gap in whats commonly published.
Snakebite Prevention
The first step in surviving a snake bite is to avoid it. Don’t get bitten, and you have nothing to worry about. Avoiding snakes, and avoiding behaviors when encountering snakes that increase the likelyhood of a bite, are absolutely key.
Wearing high-top boots, ideally of thick leather, or snake-bite resistant gaiters is an excellent first step in preventing envenomation, but are only truly necessary when first line precautions haven’t been taken or are impossible due to environment or situational needs.
Use care and caution about where you are moving, where your feet are going and where your stride takes you. Particularly when moving across areas that would be likely to harbor and conceal snakes. Brush, tall grass, loose rocks, boulders, deadfall, and human debris/garbage are all prime spots for snakes. Sometimes you won’t see a snake until you are very near, or right above, it. Moving carefully reduces the possibility of unexpectedly overtaking our shoulderless friend.
When dealing with rattlesnakes you have a distinct advantage in usually receiving a warning buzz from them, often before they are seen. Some do not buzz, and some are simply difficult to hear, so it’s never safe to assume there is no snake because there is no buzz. With rattlers, it is merely an added advantage to knowing where they are and avoiding them. This can also be a problem coming from an environment where 99% of the concern is toward rattlers – It’s easy to be spoiled by having an auditory warning, and forget that many venomous snakes have no such capability. Similarly, people in-experienced with rattlers, often are confused by the noise, failing to recognize it as a danger sign, or making stupid moves attempting to identify or locate the source. It is important when going into unfamiliar environments to take note of the snakes of the area and their habits as part of your environmental safety evaluations.
Most people who get bitten by snakes are bitten because they did something stupid. They were unaware, failed to recognize warnings, or failed to act in an appropriate manner. It’s not hard to not be stupid with snakes. Watch where you’re putting your feet. Look over ledges before you step off them. Be aware of potential snake-rich areas, and approach them with caution. Use tools to locate snakes to avoid them. Use a trekking pole, or long stick, to probe materials you need to walk or reach through or under. Throw rocks into brush, or rock slides or under ledges.
If you encounter a snake, don’t fuck with it. Leave it be, give it a wide berth, and keep on trucking. Most snakes are not aggressive, and simply want to be left alone. A snake that’s been interfered with and pissed off, however, will act aggressively. Similarly snakes in other forms of distress will behave aggressively. Do your part to not contribute to their foul mood, and you won’t have much to worry about. Some snakes, water moccasins in particular, are aggressive and territorial. I’ve personally encountered that behavior with Mojave rattlers as well, but that’s not conclusive. Use caution, stay out of their way, and avoid contact with potentially aggressive snakes as much as possible (just like any other snake). If you, for some reason, cannot get away from an aggressive snake, kill it. Most snakes will leave you alone, but when necessary, don’t hesitate to kill one quickly.
Snakebite First Aid
Snakebite as used here refers to an bite and envenomation from a venomous snake. Plain, simple, non-venomous snake bite should be treated like any other simple puncture wound from a nasty, germ/bacteria riddled, object.
Treatment of vemomous snakebite in the field, absent a well supplied medical doctor hidden in your backpack, is largely a fallacy. The most (and best) that can be done in the field is support and transport in these cases. In the absence of certainty, the bite should be treated as venomous and the bitten transported to the nearest medical facility, or intercept with emergency medical services.
There are various tools on the market, sold as “Snakebite Kits”, which are of (at best) nebulous value. Most feature a mechanical negative-pressure device designed to “suck” the venom out of the wound. Many also feature a tourniquet, and a scalpel blade, supposedly to constrain the venom to the injured limb, and to open up the bite site for easier suction of the venom. These ideas have been widely discredited in the medical community as wastes of time at best, if not outright dangerous.
I pretty commonly hear the tourniquet and cutting methods discredited by laypeople, but there are a lot of people still carrying various types of suction devices. Primary among these is the Sawyer Extractor, but others exist and are still commonly carried and recommended.
There is strong evidence that these types of tools both fail to extract a significant (if any) amount of venom, and that they may in fact cause further damage to the tissue and vessels surrounding the bite leading to increased necrosis.
In a study reported in the February 2004 edition of Annals of Emergency Medicine by Alberts, Shallit and LoGalbo (Suction for venomous snakebite: A study of “mock venom” extraction in a human model - http://www.annemergmed.com/article/S0196-0644(03)00813-8/abstract ), 8 patients were injected with simulated fangs and a mock venom marked with radioactive particles. At 3-minutes a Sawyer Extractor was then applied to the “envenomation” sites, and after fifteen minutes of suction the blood collected and analyzed for venom content. The removed fluid was found to contain less than 1% of the injected venom. The study’s authors concluded that this “suggests that suction is unlikely to be an effective treatment for reducing the total body venom burden after a venomous snakebite.”
In the same, February 2004, edition of Annals of Emergency Medicine, an editorial by Dr. Sean Bush, MD, FACEP, titled “Snakebite Suction Devices Don’t Remove Venom: They Just Suck”, compared the study and its findings to previous dismissals of tourniquets and incisions across the bites. In the editorial Bush notes that, in a study he authored, increased tissue damage was associated with use of the Sawyer extractor, “The conclusion of the study was that the Extractor did not reduce swelling, but resulted in further injury in some subjects. Specifically, circular lesions identical in size and shape to the Extractor suction cups developed where the devices had been applied. These lesions subsequently necrosed, sloughed, and resulted in tissue loss that prolonged healing by weeks. Similar injuries after Extractor use have been noted in human patients.” In short, these types of gadgets are more of a piss in the wind than panacea.
So, without gadgetry for support, what should be done? The best medicine for snake bites remains rapid patient support, and transportation to definitive care.
Aside from basic Advanced Cardiac Life Support (ACLS) type support for the patient, and transport, there is very little that can be done in the field for snakebites. This is particularly true for bites from pit vipers (Crotalids, the predominant type of poisonous snake in North America).
There is a management method applicable to Elapidae family snakes, common in Australia/Asia. Pressure Immobilization Technique (PIT), also known as Australian Method (for where it was developed), is the standard for field care of snakebites in Australia and Asia. The method involves wrapping the bitten extremity in compression bands (ACE bandages) from the bite site, to the trunk, and back again. The limb is then splinted to ensure immobility (Australian Wilderness Medical Institute guidelines for Elapid Envenomation, http://www.wmi.net.au/wmi/Uploads/FAI/20050510_curriculum%20updates.pdf). This prevents or at least reduces systemic spread of the venom until the bands are removed (in a clinical setting with immediately available antivenin). For elapidae, this method works exceedingly well, but it presents problems when dealing with crotalid envenomation.
Elapidae are primarily neurotoxic in their venoms, where-as crotalids are hemotoxic. PIT, when applied to crotalid envenomations, traps the tissue damaging venom and greatly increases intracompartmental pressures, greatly increasing the tissue damage done by crotalid venom. There is very little benefit in reduced mortality to weigh against the increased tissue damage. A 2004 study by Dr. Sean Bush et al (Pressure Immobilization Delays Mortality and Increases Intracompartmental Pressure After Artificial Intramuscular Rattlesnake Envenomation in a Porcine Model, Annals of Emergency Medicine, December 2004, http://www.llu.edu/llu/faculty/whayes/documents/2004_bush_et_al._pressure-immob.pdf) showed that when used on Western Diamondback envenomation, PIT delayed mortality by 23%, but increased intracompartmental pressure by 179%. In discussion, Bush et al reference other studies showing improved mortality rates when PIT is used, but increased possibility for tissue damage. Based on their results, Bush et al said, “On the basis of our findings, we cannot recommend pressure immobilization widely for viper envenomation, although specific scenarios may warrant its use. Individuals who chose to consider pressure immobilization will still have to assess risks versus benefits versus alternatives on a case-by-case basis. An informed decision should take into consideration factors such as the size and species of snake, the patient’s size, duration and location of fang contact, previous exposures to snake venom, and time and accessibility to medical care and antivenom.”
An editorial sidebar to Pressure Immobilization Delays (…) stated, “Pressure immobilization should be discouraged for bites that involve venoms that produce substantial local injury, such as the rattlesnake, copperhead, and cottonmouth snakes of the United States.”
This is the standard of care for snakebite in North America, where pit vipers are predominant. Pressure immobilization is to be avoided. If working in an area of mixed snake populations, this is one of the (many) reasons to have a good working knowledge of the snakes in your area, or the area where you will be working/traveling, including being able to identify them on sight.
In addition to, or when PIT is contraindicated, patients need to be supported in accordance with standard ACLS guidelines for Airway, Breathing and Circulation. If available, Oxygen and fluids via large bore IV’s are commonly recommended (Snakebite,Daley and Barbee, published via Medscape’s eMedicine site, http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/168828-overview. Snake Envenomation; Mohave Rattle, Bush, published via Medscape’s eMedicine site, http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/771586-treatment ).
Minimizing activity, and removal of jewelry and clothing potentially involved in the expected swelling of the bitten extremity is also recommended when applicable. If it’s necessary to walk the victim out of a remote area, these measures may need to be delayed until a vehicle, or EMS intercept point, is reached.
Encouraging calm and relaxation is also encouraged, to keep the patients heart rate low and decrease systemic spread of venom. Also recommended is continued monitoring of the victims vitals, and observation for advancing symptoms, such as increased occlusion of the airway due to swelling.
Patient and injury history will be very important to note, particularly once the bitten has been delivered to medical care. Note the type and size of the snake, the time of the bite, and the patients condition as it evolves between bite and delivery to care. Mark the increase in effected tissue every fifteen minutes or so. Take note of time from bite to onset of symptoms, and of pain level at time of bite, and as symptoms progress. Make note of any medications the patient is on, while they remain conscious and lucid enough to recount these details. When delivering the patient to EMS or the hospital, all these details will be important.
Looking at the information provided by the sources previously referenced, we can establish a rough guideline for field management of snakebite as the following:
Contact Emergency Medical Services.
Identify (if possible) the snake.
Expose the bite, removing potentially constricting clothing from the area.
Mark the extent of envenomation (visible via swelling), and continue to re-mark every 15 minutes to track progess.
If Elapid, and the victim does not need to be walked out of remote area, use Pressure Immobilization
Give Oxygen and intravenous fluids if available.
Continue to monitor patient condition and vitals. Intubate if available/necessary to combat airway occlusion from swelling.
Encourage calm and minimize physical movement/exertion of victim.
Avoid administering any therapies that lack value, or may increase risks, such as administration of aspirin, use of ice or electrical shock, tourniquet application, ingestion of alcohol, and home remedies. Use energy and time for medically sound patient support, and rapid transport to advanced care.
This is a really rough, quick and dirty overview of some of the current findings and thinking in snakebite care in the field. There is a lot more reading that can, and probably should, be done (certainly if you are a provider), but this should give you a start and a working beginning for your needs in the field.
Be safe, and tread easily – Sammy NoShoulders is out there!
No comments:
Post a Comment